18 Shake vs Isagenix: The Ultimate Comparison

What is the 18 Shake Diet?

Fatigue is physical exhaustion – brain fog, burnout.
For autoship and membership. That's high for a weight loss product. II , Orville T. You can also find the shakes on Amazon. They are nutritionally balanced and have a tested and proven taste acceptance across all cultures.

Does Shakeology Really Work?

18 Shake vs Shakeology – Which is Better for Weight Loss?

This "expert review" is clearly just an advertisement for a competitor of Shakeology. And no, I don't sell it. I really like Shakeology. Keeps me full, keeps my energy levels up and is convenient. Chocolate is my favorite flavor. It is painfully obvious to me, after reading several of your different product reviews, that you are only finding ways to tear down other products in order to promote your own.

This is unreliable information. Shakeology has become a lifesaver for me. I was out of control eating junk foods. Now I can turn to a simple shake to curb those cravings, fill my nutritional needs, and keep my nutrition plan on track. Not only was this not effective but when I tried to cancel my subscription they made if very difficult.

The website is not user friendly. They charged me for another order even after I believed I had cancelled my subscription. I like shakeology of course is a matter of having good eating habits and exercise.

I have been using Shakeology for 3 months; I drink it every day and follow the beachbody exercise plans and I lost about 15 lbs in 3 months, I have never felt as fit as I feel now. It also helped my digesting system to be more regular. The label for 18 Shake says there are only 16 servings in a bag. Shakeology has 30 servings. Compare the labels side by side and you will find that Shakeology has much higher concentrations in damn near every category.

The fiber used in 18 Shake, Fibersol-2, is a chemically processed digestion resistant maltodextrin corn-based fiber. In other words, the body will absorb more of the nutrients instead of passing them out of the body unused.

Currently, Fibersol-2 does not meet the FDA's definition of a "dietary fiber". I've been using Shakeology, not as a meal replacement, but as an addition to my diet. I eat 3 meals each day, plus a snack and a Shake. I do exercise each day for 30 minutes. I have lost 8 lbs. I love the taste of the shakes. I usually add things like walnuts and kale or spinach, and a piece of banana. I have more energy. I have nothing but good things to say about Shakeology. Except the strawberry flavor tastes like vomit, but I don't like strawberry flavored things to begin with!

Chocolate and Cafe Latte are awesome! Vanilla is good, too. I recommend Shakeology with no reservations. I really love Shakeology, never had a problem with it.

It really is a meal replacement for me and have felt its been worth it for me, since i have been able to managed to have my breakfast ready and drink it on my way to work. Im not trying to lose weight with it but i have lost a few pounds.

Just make sure you have your snacks if you get hungry, which most of the time i dont get any cravings. Shakeology Nutrition is a company that offers meal replacement protein shakes. These healthy shakes offer a delicious alternative to the tasteless shakes you might be used to. You can use Shakeology shakes as a meal replacement or in place of a snack.

The shakes are manufactured by Beach Body Fitness which is known for their many home workout systems. Shakeology shakes have low glycemic numbers and the ingredients include various fruits and vegetables.

These shakes include 70 healthy ingredients and they help your body eliminate toxins. You can use these shakes to lose weight, feel energized, lower cholesterol and improve digestion and regularity. The shakes keep you full for a longer period of time and allow you to maintain your energy levels throughout the day. Staying full will keep you from eating and help you lose weight.

Shakeology products contain 23 vitamins and minerals as well as various digestive enzymes, proteins and essential amino acids. There are several recipes available so you can add some variety to your shakes.

A full program including diet and exercise advice is available on the Shakeology web site. These shakes have no caffeine and no refined sugars or artificial sweeteners. There are over 70 ingredients in these shakes, so just a few are highlighted. The ingredients below are taken from the chocolate Shakeology shake:. Add 1 full scoop 48 g of Shakeology powder to 8 oz.

It can also be mixed in a blender with ice for a creamy, frosty smoothie. The Shakeology program comes with recommendations on how you should eat and workout plans. The workouts available include The 30 and The The 30 is a 30 minute workout that you do three times per week. Once you feel strong enough, you can rotate in The 50 once per week to challenge yourself. Eventually you will move to doing the 50 minute workout three times per week.

Both workouts are a good blend of cardiovascular intervals, muscle building strength moves and metabolism boosters. Overall the meal plan is that you replace one meal per day with a Shakeology shake. Those that replaced one meal per day with a shake were able to drop an average of ten pounds and two inches from their waist in 90 days. It is recommended on the eating plan that you eat a total of five meals each day with one being a shake. It is also recommended that you eat every two to three hours to keep your metabolism working.

Protein and fat should be consumed in moderation and incorporating food high in fiber is also helpful. Drinking plenty of water to keep your body hydrated is also very important. Below is a sample menu day while on the Shakeology program:.

Shakeology shakes can be a great tool in your diet and exercise plan. You are only replacing one meal per day with a shake, and you eat several times per day. If you follow the nutrition and exercise program, you are sure to lose some weight and get healthy. The information provided within this site is strictly for the purposes of information only and is not a replacement or substitute for professional advice, doctors visit or treatment.

The provided content on this site should serve, at most, as a companion to a professional consult. It should under no circumstance replace the advice of your primary care provider.

You should always consult your primary care physician prior to starting any new fitness, nutrition or weight loss regime. All trademarks, registered trademarks and service-marks mentioned on this site are the property of their respective owners. Does It Really Work? Does Shakeology Really Work? Top Rated Diet Shakes of Web MD has reviewed this additive and concluded: However, Web MD has once again found: This ingredient is also threatened to become an endangered fruit.

Even things like body weight can affect how well one responds to ingredients like this. Potential side effects can include: It can potentially lead to side effects that include: Possible side effects can include: Other possible side effects may include: A study by the Oregon Health Division expressed concern over this ingredient: The University of Maryland Medical Center has also reviewed this as a protein source: The University of California Davis performed a study showing major side effects: Multiple studies have confirmed that fructose can promote: A study by the Pennington Biomedical Research Center reviewed this ingredient and they concluded: They also go on to say: One customer on a BeachBody forum added: They do add a mixture of different marketing claims which make Shakeology seem like a quality meal replacement shake such as: Customers had the following to say: Here is the listed ratio of Shakeology reviews and overall business reviews: According to the official website: The official website adds: A good meal posted Jun 4th, 6: Melissa It works very well for me.

Nikki It was awful. It does curb my appettie posted Apr 20th, 8: Nell So Shakeology worked so well for me for about a month before I got sick. Steph I am at the end of my 2nd bag of Shakeology. Bee Reste Lost 5lbs per week with a total loss of 4 stone 7 lbs in 11 months. Sam This so-called review is clearly just an advertisement for a competitor of Shakeology.

There is no focus on superfood blends at all. Instead, the shakes use a compound called fibersol This is a patented type of fiber that is meant to suppress appetite. Fiber tends to suppress appetite. There is even some research supporting fibersol-2 1 , 2. But, does it work better than other types of fiber? Besides, the fiber content is 5 grams per serving. There are many similarities between the brands. But, Shakeology offers more plant-based ingredients that may be beneficial, along with much more sugar.

Customers are often biased by personal perspectives and experiences. Many have no basis for comparison either. Instead, people often try shakes until they find one that works. They then stick with that brand. Plus, there are distributors and affiliates for these brands, who have their own motivations.

Some people find that the shakes work well and taste fine as well. In fact, many positive reviews rely on smoothie recipes to mask some of the taste of the powder. Doing so is an option — but a frustrating one. Reviews for Shakeology tend to be positive. You still need to add extra ingredients. This is true for most protein shakes but it does add to the price. Adding other ingredients is mostly a nutrition decision. The most common critique is simply, why bother?

Distributors often focus on the way that the shakes are worth the price. You can also afford them by cutting out junk and takeout. This is mostly true — as long as you were eating junk initially. Still, the argument ignores that there are cheaper brands that offer the same general benefits. For those who have the money, Shakeology could be a good choice. At worst, the company has aggressive marketing and high pricing.

But, the products themselves should work fine and reviews support that idea. The products from Shakeology get more positive reviews, on average. But, both are popular and have passionate customers. There is no clear winner between Shakeology and 18 Shake. The best choice depends on what you need. My personal preference of the two is 18 Shake. The main advantage of Shakeology is the superfood and probiotic focus - but you can get those benefits from real food.

Many smoothies offer those benefits anyway. For example, you could make any one of these superfood smoothies from Legion Athletics and add protein powder to the recipe. You could also choose additions like wheatgrass powder or spirulina for extra nutrients.

The best brand is going to depend on what you need. Both of these brands do work and offer different advantages. But, there are countless other options. Some are more powerful nutritionally, while others are much less expensive. The table below highlights key alternatives and you can check out our recommended protein powders page for more. Axe also offers 23 protein shake recipes that you could try out using any of these powders. Weight loss is a huge industry, with no shortage of hype. But, long-term weight loss doesn't come from a crash diet or a popular fad.

Check out my recommended weight loss products to see where you can get started. Article Navigation The Brands. Shakes are a popular way to lose weight — but which product do you turn to? There are many options out there, some are much better than others. This post compares 18 Shake vs Shakeology, two brands that are popular in their own right. Each of the brands has many passionate followers. So, which one is better? The Brands 18 Shake.

The site heavily relies on hype and sales tools. You have to provide your address and phone number to even see the pricing.

The site feels very manipulative, with an excessive emphasis on marketing and few details. In fact, most of the Shakeology hype comes from distributors, not customers. Like 18 Shake, there are some other products present. The main ones are the boosts below. This is a wider selection of flavors and includes some more unusual options. The chocolate flavor seems to be favored over the vanilla option. Some 18 Shake diet reviews say they have gotten great results with the program.

We want to take a minute to look at some of the other options out there, as well as a side-by-side comparison to some popular competitors. It contains 20 vitamins and minerals and only has one gram of fat — and no sugar. Both of these shakes are among the most popular meal replacement options available on the market today. One serving of Shakeology has calories, so obviously 18 Shake wins in that category. Shakeology has 17 grams of protein, but their protein comes from pea protein, which is a vegan source.

Both shakes use whey protein. But Shakeology wins for the variety of protein they offer. But, it contains twice as many calories, four times the sugar, only 9 grams of protein, and only 8 grams of fiber. IdealShape comes in 15 flavors and is more affordable. Chocolate coconut, chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, banana cream pie, chocolate peanut butter, cookies n cream, vanilla chai, mint chocolate, eggnog, mocha, salted caramel, chocolate cream pie, superfood blend dark chocolate stevia sweetened, orange cream, cinnamon bun, key lime, and vanilla superfood blend stevia sweetened.

It uses a different hunger blocker. Where 18 Shake uses Fibersol, IdealShake uses Slendesta — but 18 Shake contains more protein, less sugar, and fewer calories.

Slendesta is a potato protein extract. Herbalife has a bit smaller portion size, at 25g compared to the It contains less protein — only nine grams. It also contains less fiber, at only 9 grams, but this is a hefty fiber dose compared to many other competing shakes. One container of Herbalife contains 30 servings. Not only is Herbalife more affordable, but offers a ton of flavors on top of it, making this our choice out of the two.

Isagenix has a bigger variety of flavor options, like: Pumpkin Spice is a seasonal flavor, with other seasonal flavors released accordingly. Isagenix has several types of shakes. They have one that uses whey protein like the 18 Shake, but they also have a dairy free range that use plant based proteins.

The dairy free shakes are also soy and gluten free. With that bigger portion size comes more calories, but if we cut them down to the same size roughly, Isagenix still has more sugar, more fat, and less fiber. The protein content is about the same. It is also free of soy, sugar, and gluten, contains 15g of high quality plant-based proteins, and is naturally sweetened. It only contains five grams of fiber.

Like most other alternatives to 18 Shake, Shake has a wider selection of flavors to choose from, including:. The proteins come from peas, brown rice, and hemp. Along with some diet modifications I have lost 8 lbs. Slow is the way to go. I blend with ice cubes, almond milk light and whatever fruit, veggies, flavorings, even coffee. One of my favorites is pineapple and kale. Have found it great for my GI function.

Will this shake take you to the next level, delivering weight loss, appetite suppression, energy, and increased performance? We liked some of the research behind the ingredients, but there were too many negatives for us to honestly support this supplement. If you want to lose weight and curb your hunger, there are better supplements out there. Choose a product that delivers on its promises — and is backed by positive customer testimonials. One of the products we like the most is Burn TS.

Choose a video to embed